Italian Citizenship Court Cases

You have won your court case and are now recognized as an Italian citizen! This is an important milestone, but the journey does not quite end with the judge’s ruling. Read on to learn about the last important document you will need to obtain in order to have your municipality register your records so you can apply for your Italian passport.

What is the Certificate of Non-Appeal, and why do you need it?

The Certificate of Non-Appeal, known in Italian as the Passaggio in giudicato, is a document that certifies that the ruling for your Italian citizenship has been finalized and is uncontested. It is important to note that once the judge issues the ruling, there is a window—usually 30 days—in which the Ministry of Interior can appeal the decision. If the ruling had not been served to the Ministry, then this window can be six month, but this is a rare case.

Only after you have the Certificate of Non-Appeal can your ancestor’s Italian municipality register your vital records and finalize the documentation related to your Italian citizenship, so it is a crucial document to have.

How do you obtain the certificate?

Up until 2022, the certificate could only be obtained in person, at the court that issued the ruling, but now it is possible to download the certificate online. The steps are as follows:

  • Wait for the appeal period to pass (as mentioned above, this is usually 30 days with rare exceptions)
  • Pay the associated tax (more on this below)
  • Upload the payment receipt on the court’s portal and issue a formal request for the certificate
  • Wait for the court to verify the payment (this might require a follow-up on your part, see below)
  • Receive your certificate from the court

The role of the Agenzia delle Entrate

As mentioned above, once the window for appeal has closed, the applicant will need to pay an associated tax before the Certificate of Non-Appeal can be issued. Usually, this fee is around €100, but it depends on the court. The clerk will send the ruling to the local revenue agency—called the Agenzia delle Entrate—which will then generate a payment notice for the applicant. Due to the necessity of close communication between the Agenzia delle Entrate and the court, and the likelihood of delays, it might become necessary to follow up with the Agenza to ensure they issue the payment notice and/or inform the court of when the tax has been paid. This is something the applicant’s attorney can easily handle.

Once the applicant has paid the tax, the attorney can upload the receipt on the court’s online portal, along with a request to obtain the Certificate of Non-Appeal. The court will need to verify the payment with the Agenza delle Entrate, along with the fact that there have been no appeals. After this is finished, the court will issue the certificate, often in the form of a digital stamp or even whole other page that is attached the initial ruling.

What happens after you obtain the certificate?

Once the applicant has the Certificate of Non-Appeal, it will then need to be sent to the municipality so they can register it along with your vital records. This cannot be done digitally, but rather a paper copy must be sent through the post office. The vital records the municipality will need as well, include the records submitted as part of the citizenship application, e.g. the applicant’s birth, marriage and divorce (if applicable), records, as well as the same records for any other family members included in the application.

Municipalities will have six months to finalize the registration of these records. Only after this is done can the newly recognized Italian citizens register with A.I.R.E. (if residing outside of Italy) and apply for their Italian passport.

Closing remarks and how ICA can help

Generally speaking, from the time the ruling is issued it can take around two months for the Certificate of Non-Appeal to be obtained. However, processing times vary greatly from court to court, and as mentioned above, the necessity of communication between the court and Agenzia delle Entrate that processes the tax can create further delays. For this reason, it might be important to follow up multiple times, which is something that case workers at ICA are well-equipped to handle on the part of the applicant. We understand when following up is appropriate and what sorts of processing times to expect. If you would like to get in touch for help with your own citizenship case, contact us today at [email protected].